Reflections on Libya’s Revolution

As an outsider it is difficult to understand the full merit of any revolution, particularly when the ‘call to arms’ in my own country, England, seemed more focused on self-enrichment through theft and mindless rioting. Yet in other parts of the world the Egyptians have shown us all the power of a meaningful revolution, while others, also subject to the rising of their people, are clinging on to whatever fumes of power and authority remain. With Assad of Syria and Gadaffi of Libya attacking their own citizens, we are also subject to the laughable prescription from the king of Saudi Arabia, delivering a warning to respect the wishes of his own citizens. The region is a mess.

Osama Bin Laden, wherever he is, dead or alive, is probably kicking himself. Like it or hate it, his call for a revolution was a decade too soon. Had he waited for the evolution of the internet, driving a campaign today via twitter, he may have been able to mimic the outcome of the Egyptian spring in Saudi Arabia. Of course the difference being that while in Egypt the call was for justice and freedom, the call pronounced by OBL was towards a more religious-centric society; that is to say the latter’s appeal was not towards the Egyptian style of revolution more towards replacing one form of tyranny with another. Imagine calling a society for religious reform based on the ugly face of ultra-conservative Islam, putting aside the fact that only those with closed minds such as Anders Breviek might heed the call, it isn’t religious authority but religious freedom that gives any nation success.

Prophet Muhammad once said that the person who harms a non-Muslim living amongst the Muslims, it is as if they have harmed him directly. This isn’ta phrase that should be light on the tongue for it’s meaning and implication are truly profound. 1400+ years ago, not only did the Prophet instill the values of respect and justice towards all, but he stressed the importance of protecting minority communities. At the most extreme interpretation, another of his statements sheds lights: Do not allow your dislike of a people lead you to be unjust towards them.

These values of freedom have drawn the line between those of us living in the ‘free world’ vs others. Yet ironically it is these same values of freedom which are being loosely tossed around like a salad. The French businessman Rachid Nekkaz who has set up a fund to pay fines for women wearing face veils is perhaps the epitome of this freedom. Like the vast majority of Muslims, he actually disagrees with the face veil, yet, he will stand up for a person’s right to dress as they like. This isn’t about religion, it is about the values of freedom, and the message of justice. If societies continue to blur these lines – for cheap political gain – then we become no different to the oppressors we criticise elsewhere.

During the early days of Islam there was a man named Shas ibn Qays. He was an older man who disliked Islam, and one day, when walking past a group of Prophet Muhammad’s companions he became envious at their happiness and unity, such that, he pronounced to himself, ‘If the chiefs of the tribe of Qayla in this country unite, there will be no place for our tribe with them.’ Ironically, the stability and success of Mecca at the time was not in mutual co-operation and goodwill, rather found in the instability of the differing warring tribes. If some of the tribes united, they might pose a threat to the other tribes. And so he sent a young boy to sit with that group of men instructing him to relate the story of the battle of Bu’ath.

During this battle two tribes, the Aus and the Khazraj fought, with one being victorious. As the young boy began reciting poetry – a way of story telling, suggesting the strength of one tribe over the other, tempers flared, and the peace these people had, had crumbled. Long story short, they became angry and decided to go to war. As news reached the Prophet he called them together reminding them that the past is the past and they must work together to secure the future. Realising their foolishness their apologised to one another. This to me sums up where not only Libya, but much of the Muslim world is today.

Just for a moment, forget faith, because actually, this isn’t about faith – if you ask every one of these people they will all confirm that they believe in One God. This is about tribes and clubs. This is about pride and arrogance. Whether it’s in the changing Muslim world or the static Muslim world, this is about ancestry and entitlement. It is actually the same story of when the black stone was being placed in the Kaba, every tribe wanted to do it, but peace was only found when every tribe was able to do it.

As I sit here watching events unfold in the Muslim world, I’m not interested in the motivations eluded to by OBL, nor those of the Taleban – I’ve simply never understood either of their causes or the rationale either chose to adopt for murdering and inflicting injustice en masse.

Love it or hate it, Arabia became Saudi Arabia as the tribe of Saud was able to unite the different tribes of Arabia under a single umbrella to deliver stability and thus generate excessive wealth. It is that wealth  which ensured that the tribe remained in place, so long as other tribes are paid off handsomely for their solemn acceptance. How critical can any of us be of that given that it is the same stability which ensures a relatively steady supply of oil ensuring the global economy churns – I do not know.

What I do know is that Libya’s oil fields are vast. It’s the reason why we are in Libya and not in Syria. What I hope however is that in securing peace and stability, the Libyans look beyond tribal loyalty and adopt a form of democracy. Sure, this is what was tried in Afghanistan and has proven to be a laughable joke – as once again for anything to be done it has to go through the lines of tribal authority, all the while those on top of the pyramid are enriching themselevs at the cost of their citizens.

Technology has delivered an impressive change, the problem is, bits and bytes are easy to program, people’s attitudes and allegiances are not.

As Libya enters a new era, I pray they find success through mutual co-operation, justice and accountability. The older example of Saudi Arabia’s stability and the more recent example of Afghanistan’s instability are evidence to suggest this will not happen. Still it is a new world. Egypt is setting an interesting precedent and we are all learning something new everyday. Who knows, perhaps the Libyans will be able to do a better job. Time alone will tell.

As for me, as an outsider, as a person with a small voice, the best I can offer is a prayer of goodwill. And may that which is better for the people of Libya be made easy for the people of Libya, ameen.

Posted in Islam, Ramadan | Leave a comment

Back-biting and the 11 women

During the month of ramadan our airwaves are filled with certain slimy tv personalities, which to me are very much the same as the zany preachers you find on US tv – it seems that zany people with zany points of view always seem to find themselves onto large public platforms. As a result of some criticisms, a discussion on back-biting has begun around which I’m sharing the following thoughts:

Allah Almighty says in the Quran, “O you who believe! Avoidsuspicion, for some suspicions are a sin. Do not spy on one another, nor backbite one another. Would one of you love to eat the flesh of his dead brother? No, you would not like it so similarly avoid back-iting., And fear Allah. Indeed, Allah is Most Forgiving, Most Merciful.” Qur’an, [49:12]

Similarly the hadith are full of criticisms of back back-biting, for example, “Whoever believes in Allah and the Last Day should say [something] good, or he should keep silent.” And yet, Aisha narrates that once a man sought an audience with the Prophet where he replied, ‘Give him permission, but he is a bad member of his tribe (Bukhari)’.’ Similarly the Prophet once said, ‘I do not believe such and such a person understands anything of our faith (Bukhair).’

Did Prophet Muhammad just back-bite two people, or is there more to the subject of back-biting than a simple ‘do not speak negatively about someone’?

While the general view on backbiting is that it is prohibited, an-Nawawi in his text Riyaadh as-saliheen expanded on the understanding of the Quranic prohibition. He opined that there are six circumstances in which back-biting is permitted:

1. Oppression: You can complain about a leader, ruler, someone in authority who has denied you a right. While this isn’t mentioned in the text specifically, I would extend this to include any public figure who has an influence which impacts any non-public figure – for the same reason.

2. Changing a wrong: When an injustice is done, then seeking help to overcome that injustice. E.g. if a wife is mistreated by a husband, she has the right to seek help from counsellors, lawyers, family members, friends, etc

3. Warning against wrongdoings: For example when a person narrates a hadith either incorrectly or falsely. That person is labelled a liar. Or when you engage in a business transaction, a marriage relationship or any form of engagement, it is one should disclose a persons faults if those faults may influence the outcome of that contract e.g. if a man agrees to marry a woman but the woman doesn’t know he has a dozen kids from a previous marriage, if you know, then it is your responsibility to step in and advise her. Should she mary him anyway, that’s her prerogative, but she should have full knowledge.

4. Exposing an act of evil: For example when a person does something wrong in public by virtue of making that act public he/she is subject to criticism. However should a person commit the act in private he/she may not be subject to criticism based on the impact that has. For example if someone drinks in public that you can criticise them for doing so, however if someone drinks in private, and by doing so doesn’t affect anyone other than themselves, unless this has an impact on their daily activities then there is no right to disclose this.

5. Seeking a religious ruling: When someone deals unjustly with you, you have the right to raise it with someone able to issue an ruling of authority e.g. a judge.

6.Defining someone: If someone is known by a nickname e.g. the deaf guy, or the blind guy, or the one who limps, or the flat-nosed, then by virtue of it being a way of recognizing the person you’re allowed to speak about the person’s traits.

These are the six main points raised and Allah knows best.

I’d add to this that, there are a couple of additional thoughts I have:

1. Intention: if the intention is simply to mock someone for the sake of mocking them, then we should avoid that as it’s a sign of bad character. However, if my criticising someone we seek to (a) share our concerns about an individual and (b) raise awareness of our concerns about an individual, especially if the individual is a public figure, then I do not understand this to be the type of backbiting that has been prohibited

2. Action: In this day and age, the ability to action upon an criticism is more difficult given the volumes of people involves, the means of communication, and more. A person may have an audience of 20 million and yet your ability to reach them or those around them may be limited or restricted. In such cases, if we talk for the sake of talking then I would say we’re doing wrong. But if we’re talking to raise concerns, sharing those concerns, with a view that somehow, perhaps one day, they might be addressed, then I do not see this as wrong.

To conclude, I finish with the story of the 11 women.

Aisha says that once 11 women assembled and made an agreement, that each of them would describe the true state of their husbands without hiding any facts.

FIRST WOMAN: My husband is like the meat of a useless camel. And the meat also put on top of a mountain which is difficult to climb. The road to the top is not easy so that it may be possible to climb it, nor is the meat of such worth, that because of it one should separate it into a hundred portions and bring it down.

SECOND WOMAN: I fear that if I begin to describe his faults there will be no end to it. If I begin I will have to mention all of his inner and outer faults.

THIRD WOMAN: My husband is an Ashannaq (i.e. a tall man, the statement is that ‘tall men are stupid’ which is what is implied here). If I ever comment on anything he will immediately say talaaq (i.e. divorce), if I keep silent, I just hang around

FOURTH WOMAN: My husband is mild mannered, like the nights of Tihaamah. He is neither hot nor cold, nor is there anything to fear of him, nor any displeasure.

FIFTH WOMAN: When my husband comes into the house, he becomes a cheetah, and when he goes out, he becomes a lion. He does not care to investigate what happens in the house.

SIXTH WOMAN: When my husband eats, he eats everything. When he drinks, he does not leave anything. When he sleeps, he sleeps in his own sheet. He does not even touch me, so that he can know the disturbance in my mind.

SEVENTH WOMAN: My husband is impotent and unmanly.He is such a dunce that he cannot even speak. Whatever sickness a person has in this world, he posses it. His manners are such that he may break my head or injure my body, or do both.

EIGHTH WOMAN: My husband is soft like a rabbit when I touch him. His smell is like the fragrance of Saffron. I dominate him, and he dominates all other people. My domination is not due to his humbleness, because he dominates others. My domination is because of love, of the politeness in him.

NINTH WOMAN: My husband is of a high status (i.e. either a big house, or a house on high ground where travelers could come and stay because of their generosity as per Arab custom), generous, hospitable, owner of a high dwelling. He has allot of ashes. He is tall built. His home is near the majlis and Darul Mashwarah (House of Counsel).

TENTH WOMAN: My husband is Maalik, and what can I say about Maalik? He is more generous than all of those who have been praised, or he is more praiseworthy than all the praises I shower on him. He owns many herds of camels, which are kept near the house. They are seldom taken out for grazing. When the camels hear the sound of the mizhar, they are sure that their end is near. [Significance of the camels not going out to graze is that if the were grazing time would be lost to bring them back to the home, instead they were kept near the house so that when a guest would come, a camel could easily be slaughtered and fed to them, this is the meaning of his generosity, that he was swift in being generous. As for the mizhar, this is an instrument. When a guest arrives they are usually served with a drink and something small to eat. When it is time for the main course, the mizhar was sounded, the meal time grew near, and that the camels would know that one of them would then be slaughtered for the meal]

ELEVENTH WOMAN: My husband was Abu Zara, and how can I praise Abu Zara? He made my ears bow with jewels. he made my sides by feeding me well. He kept me so happy and contended, that due to self admiration and haughtiness I thought I was virtuous. he found me from such a poor home that lived with hardship, owning only a few goats for a living. From there he brought me to such a prosperous family who owned, horses, camels, oxen for ploughing, and gardeners, and he did not criticise or scold me for anything. I slept late in the morning and no one was allowed to wake me up. Food was so abundant that after fulfilling myself I just left it. The mother of Abu Zara, in what way can I praise her? Her huge cooking utensils were always full. Her house was very spacious (i.e. she was very generous). The son of Abu Zara, in what manner can I praise him? He was also light upon light, he was so think and skinny that his ribs were like the branch from a sword. A side of lamb was enough to fill his stomach (he didn’t need to eat allot to be happy). The daughter of Abu Zara, how can I praise her? She obeys her mother and father. She is fat and healthy, and a jealousy for the second wife (i.e. if her husband took another wife no matter who he married the second wife would always be jealous of her). And how can I praise the slave girl of Abu Zara? She never gossiped about our house affairs to anyone. She did not even use foodstuffs without permission. She did not let the house become dirty or untidy but kept it clean. One day while the utensils were being churned, Abu Zara went out of the house. he came across a woman with two cheetah like children playing with pomegranates. He lover her so much, that he divorced me, and married her. Subsequently I married another chief and noble man, who was a prince and a soldier. He showered on me many gifts. And from each type of animal (i.e. cow, goat, camel, etc) he presented me a pair and said to me ‘Eat as much as you want for yourself, and send as much as you want to your parents’. The fact is, that even if I add up all of his good qualities they will not begin to match the smallest good thing that Abu Zara bestowed upon me.

Hearing these accounts, Prophet Muhammad said to Aisha, “I am to you, as Abu Zara had been to Umm Zara (i.e. his wife)”

[Ref: Shamaa il-Tirmidhi, # 241]

Some scholars are of the opinion that the above constitutes back biting, however, this account was made in the presence of the Prophet Muhammad and he did not criticise it. More imporatntly he added to the end of their comments to say that he was to Aisha the same way Abu Zara was towards his wife. And Allah knows best.

Is it fair therefore to criticise those on our tv screens whose points of views are being delivered into our own homes if we disagree with them? Absolutely! However I’d discourage any criticism just for the sake of it; expressing annoyance and frustration is one thing, but doing so just for the sake of doing so, can’t be a good thing, and Allah knows best.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Famines Across Time

Somalia vs Saudi Arabia

Saudi Import Somali Sheep

This photograph is from the ArabNews website showing livestock from Somalia being delivered to Saudi Arabia. Allow me to quote them:

“…shipments carrying more than a million livestock would arrive in the next few days at Jeddah port to cover local market needs for the month of Ramadan and until Haj. The availability of imported livestock in the market will help reduce prices by 10 percent…”

There isn’t actually a shortage of livestock in Saudi Arabia or in any of the other Arab Gulf countries for that matter. In fact, it is quite the opposite. And while I do not have the stats specifically for Saudi Arabia, next door in Abu Dhabi, more than 500 tonnes of food is wasted every day during Ramadan.

In the early years of Islam there was a famine in Arabia of such severity that by way of support a line of camels miles long, each bearing food was send from Egypt to Arabia. It seems as if in this modern age, instead of sending food to those suffering from a famine we are taking it away from them! Humanity at it’s best :/

We do also have waste here in England, worse I dread to imagine the stockpiles of food rotting in warehouses across the world. But these are ships coming from a region that is suffering from a famine. Someone has made the decision to import livestock, not because there is a shortage, rather to simply reduce the price, all the while the very nation it is coming from has millions dieing. May Allah Almighty forgive humanity of our greed!

I doubt it will ever be the case but should I ever be in such a position of authority, I hope I have sufficient integrity to put people before profits.

It is said that a person who does not giving up doing wrong, such as telling lies, might as well not fast, as the purpose of fasting is to improve oneself. So I wonder about the quality of the ‘fast’ of those responsible for taking food away from those suffering in a famine.

May Allah Almighty have mercy and guide us all, ameen.

Posted in Fasting, Islam, Ramadan | Leave a comment

London Riots: Another Face of Terrorism

As we near the tenth anniversary of 9/11 a stark realisation must be dawning upon those who have used certain acts of terrorism as a means of creating a bi-polar perception of humanity, a ‘them and us.’ Typically, this has been manifest in religion, specifically Islam, which has been presented as a conquering force. But as events of late have shown, this isn’t actually the case.

Just a few days ago Norway suffered the wrath of a right-wing extremist. We have been told that this was ‘unexpected,’ yet I wonder if this is complacency based on political agenda no better illustrated in the fiasco that was Herman Cain’s candidacy where he spent much time criticising Muslims only to later backtrack when he realised that his policy of gaining election through fear wasn’t quite working.

Whether it is a group of people blowing up the twin towers in NY, a group bombing the London underground, an individual murdering children in Norway, or rioters and looters in London; these and other groups have a single objective in mind, to protest – not lawfully, but through any means possible, irrespective of the consequences of their actions, be it the loss of life or the destruction of property. Crucially, the mindset is not singular to any faith group, rather it is a matter of intolerance and impatience.

I’ve been following the riots, not through traditional media rather through first hand reporting via twitter and facebook – these are real time updates where I’ve noticed published media tend to be 15-30 mins behind. On the issue of technology there have been widespread requests to shutdown the Blackberry Messenger service, which some believe has been fundamental in organising these riots, to shutting down the entire mobile network. Both are of course mute points and side issues as the same technologies are helping the emergency services and citizens report and warn on incidents.

Amongst the many groups on facebook that have popped up garnering tens of thousands of supporters is a matter of hours is one where a rioter claims that Mark Duggan, the man who was shot, around whom these riots were apparently instigated, was his friend. Putting aside reports that he was a gangster and a drug dealer, after his opening status, “I’m loving what is happening…mark was’nt just any randon guy like your self. he was some one who took care of our own comunity. in every way possible you imagine in your f head”

My initial and simple response to his statement was to question how he is honoring the death of a man who ‘looked after his own community’ by destroying the communities of other people. This, sadly, is the same mindset employed by every terrorist group – the destruction of something else, to express your own anger. Stripped down, this attitude is not a reflection of any religion, rather, it is the disturbing reality of a poor, selfish, character, unaware of the impact of his actions; just so long as when he goes home to bed at night he has safety and security – a luxury he has no hesitation in denying others.

Herman Cain isn’t a foolish man, a quick look at his bio on wikipedia shows a smart, successful businessman. Yet for someone with his position, he has shown the same level of irresponsibility as thugs currently rioting and looting; sure the two are at different extremes, the mindset is however the same.

As people of conscious, we need to redefine a few things, the first being this war on terrorism. It is already a marginalized phrase as the only terrorists it seems as (crazy) Muslims, while anyone ‘white’ is ‘disenfranchised.’ And secondly, we need to address our approach based on common values – it is possible to have very different faiths while sharing core common values.

If instead of stereotyping large swathes of our communities based on colour or creed, we focused more on understanding people and their concerns; addressing those concerns instead of sidelining them, we may be a step closer to stability in our societies.

If a person wishes to cause harm to themselves or to others, in reality there is probably very little any of us can do to stop them. However if our police and security services are going to stand a chance of doing just that, stopping them, they need the support of people across colours, across creeds; they need that relationship of trust to be in place.

The problem is, every time society suffers in this way, it is so much easier to blame someone else than to reflect on whether we were part of the problem in the first place; e.g. spending billions on wars which many of us did not believe we needed in the first place all the while basic services are being cut. Nearly 12 months ago home secretary Theresa May said, ‘We can cut police budget without risking violent unrest.’

Instead of cutting our basic services as a means of getting out of this recession, we need to start investing in our people and in our industries. For as it stands, some of the rioters opined that their stealing during akin to the bankers who we bailed out while they continue to reward themselves with excessive bonuses. If we’re going to clear the apartment block, lets look at every floor, not just the lower echelons.

As to the rioters a simple message: Mark Duggan died leaving behind three children. There is much heartache and misery. Be the better persons, and do not inflict heartache onto other people. As if he was a good person, who did good things, by  doing bad, you are dishonoring his memory.

Posted in Fasting, Islam, Ramadan | 2 Comments

Sins Of Fasting & Rioting

Compare, “You’ve fasted half of the day, you may as well carry on” vs “You shouldn’t fast when you’re this sick.” The subtle distinction between one who isn’t qualified medically and one who is. And yet, with a parched mouth with such heat that you could have easily baked a naan bread in it yesterday, I did the foolish thing. I took the advice of the one not medically qualified and I ask myself, why?

Just the other day a friend posted a link to an article on Somalis living in the famine who chose to fast. In a rather foolhardy way I pointed out that they are suffering from a famine, they are exempt from fasting. Yet it seems that despite our varying circumstances, they lack of food, water and in some cases shelter, vs the comfort of my bedroom, with drinks and edibles to hand, we both suffered from the same ‘illness.’

At the same time as I lay in bed updating facebook on my phone until I was no longer able to even lift my fingers up to type on the keypad, London was running amok. Opinions and attitudes of some towards the police may be at an all time low, based on the actions of a few, but rioting, in London, really? Here I live in one of the safest countries of the world – anyone who has visited another country, whether third world of even nearby in Europe, say Italy, knows how blatantly corrupt the police authorities can be. And yet that a few police officers broke the law doesn’t make all of them responsible for it.  Worse, that disenfranchised youth used the opportunity to riot and steal is shameful: looting isn’t a legalised concession for product acquisition during a riot, it is theft.

As a British Muslim of Pakistani heritage I am of course familiar with the notion of an entire group being blamed for the actions of a few, – just recently while attending an event where two members of the royal family were present, I was profiled by four seperate members of their security detail on four different occasion, despite having the passes and permits to be there. It isn’t a nice feeling.

That doesn’t of course make it right. Many years ago, my elder brother – may Allah Almighty have mercy on his soul – decided to become a special constable, amongst his hobbies. He wanted to give something back to his community, and in that capacity he certainly did. This marks the trust and honor afforded to the police authorities who despite facing heavy handed cuts do their best to ensure we live in as safe an environment as possible.

Coming to my point, here’s a thought. Just  the Somalis as I were so determined to complete our fasts, despite being exempt from it, the rioters and looters – admittedly small bands on them – were determined to enrich themselves through theft. Both displayed a passion for their objectives. However while I pray that the Somalies are I are blessed with forgives for our clear disrespect of God Almighty’s allowance by continuing to fast, I hope the arm of the law is considerably less forgiving differentiating between those who were simply caught up in the action vs those who were orchestrated the injustice, ensuring that the latter do not escape with a slap on the wrist.

I’ve purposefully stayed off the on-line world today as I had been ‘saving’ my energy to splurge and author this one post – back to bed for me. But a here’s closing thought. I can understand looting a sport shop, maybe even a super market, but setting afire Nandos? Really? Perhaps one of the looters wanted his chicken with a more Burger Kingesque flame-grilled look!

Posted in Fasting, Islam, Ramadan | 1 Comment

Understanding The Sermon

Just yesterday I found myself at another Friday sermon where once again the preacher spoke in a language which the majority of the audience could not understand. I’m often struck by the contrast between the Quran which stresses the importance of comprehension and understanding, which criticises blind acts of commitment, vs the insistence of the imam to speak in Arabic to a non-Arabic audience.

I do not doubt his intention nor his passion, that was clear to see in his expressions – even though his delivery could have been much better (why aren’t public speaking classes mandatory for imams?). But I’m left utterly dumbstruck by trying to understand how anyone can possibly think they are educating or reminding their congregation without being able to effectively communicate with them in a language.

Bored, I took to facebook to vent my frustrations. It’s not that I have a low attention span, it’s just that this is the window of opportunity in every week where the mosque should be delivering a message, establishing dialogue, building a community spirit. It wasn’t. People looking around, checking their watches, fidgeting, all of the signs of boredom manifest to anyone peering in from outside. Moreover, how utterly oblivious, lost in his own world, can the imam have been if he didn’t understand this when looking at his audience?

In this now-frequently disturbing weekly ritual, God-Almighty it would seem, did answer my prayer. Yes, the imam did eventually break into English, I did put my phone away and I did afford him the respect of my attention and while the sermon was ‘ok’ it was frankly uninspiring – still he tried and for that may he be blessed. This wasn’t however the miracle.

Instead, as I sat there, a cute little girl, perhaps 3 years of age, came and stood by me. Her big brown eyes, long black hair highlighted by a solitary red clip. She began playing with her fingers, looking towards me, smiling. I had lost interest in what the imam was saying (at the time in Arabic) and my attention shifted to her. She started making faces, I being the gent that I am, obliged, all the while conscious that  I’m in a room full of men, all the while reassured that they were all so uninterested in what was being said that they had switched off. Some moments later as she walked off, the imam then spoke in English.

It so happened that as the time for prayer arrived, she ended up standing alongside me. During the prayer she displayed much the same prayer mannerisms I recall having myself as a child – fidgety, standing on my toes, waving my arms excessively with each moment of prayer. What I found more interesting is that she began mimicking the imam. For example, when he would say Allahu akbar, she too would say Allahu akbar.

This copycat approach was of course expected for at that age children do mimic the actions of those around them. But when the imam cleared his throat, she copied him. He did it again, she copied him again. Then it hit me, despite our difference in age and our differing level of comprehension, we were suffering much the same.

She, not knowing any better was there with her father, fulfilling the obligations and rituals that she had seen and was being taught. I too was there trying to fulfill my obligations and rituals by attending the most important prayer of the week. Yet she has an excuse, her age, for simply copying rote fashion. As an adult however, one thankfully capable of comprehension, I have no excuse. Nor does anyone else there.

If someone tells me, we must do such and such because it is tradition, my response should be why, and I should not accept it unless the reason ‘makes sense.’ As it stands, I see no sense in preaching to people in a language they do not understand. And the wisdom behind this simple point is actually made by Allah Almighty in the Quran, where it is said, “We have sent it down as an Arabic Quran, so that your people may understand (12:2).” In fact, Allah continues to say, “We have not sent any Messenger except with the language of his people so that he can make things clear to them(14:4).”

Further, Allah addresses the very point I’m trying to make when the Quran says, “If we had made it a foreign Quran, they would have said, ‘If only its verses were clear! What? Foreign speech to an Arab…(41:44)”

Not only does God Almighty point out the obvious common sense approach of ensuring that the revelations throughout time are delivered to the respective communities in their native tongue such that they can understand. But God Almighty also observes that if that wasn’t the case then people would complain as they are unable to understand the message. So I wonder, what is better, to deliver a sermon in a language which the audience cannot understand, because tradition dictates so, or to ensure that the message of the sermon is delivered in a clear concise manner?

For me, the answer to this question can be found in another verse of the Quran, where Allah Almighty says, “We have sent down to you, Muhammad, the message, such that you may explain it clearly to the people, such that they may think and reflect (16:44).” Sadly, far too many Muslims accept tradition in place of understanding, as a result, we are more like the little 3 year old girl, having switched off our facility for comprehension and doing things for the sake of doing things. Prosperity is rarely found without comprehension, unless of course you happen to be sitting on top of huge natural resources.

“When they are asked to follow that which Allah has revealed, they say, ‘no! We would rather follow the path we found our forefathers pursuing.’ Even if their forefathers understood nothing? Even if they were misguided? (2:170).

This verse was revealed when the Prophet invited a group of people to Islam but they refused saying, ‘Rather, we shall follow what we found our forefathers following.’ To me however, the analogy is the same. We either accept the example of Allah’s wisdom where a message is meant to be delivered to its people – in this case a sermon to an audience, in a language the congregation can understand – or we continue this mindless tradition and lose the opportunity of educating, interacting and inspiring those who attend the Friday prayers. And may Allah Almighty have mercy and guide us all, ameen.

Posted in Fasting, Islam, Ramadan | 1 Comment

(Somalia) Drought, Not Famine

The first in-person reports came in last night on Channel4 news where the journalist managed to speak with a representative of Somalia’   Harakat al-Shabaab al-Mujahideen (Movement of Striving Youth). Commonly referred to as al-Shabaab, the group comprise a band of rebels in the thousands whose objective is to overthrow the Somali government. Along with the typical terrorist manifesto, they cite religion as their driving force insisting on applying an interpretation of sharia which frankly as events of late have shown, have nothing to do with the Sharia, the Quran or even Islam. Allow me to explain.

The first disgusting statement by their spokesman is that they were not suffering a famine, rather, a drought. People are dying, children are malnourished, it is estimated that up to 4 million are suffering, and they begin with a discussion on semantics – all the while it is prety clear to see what is happen via the video footage.

The second disgusting statement is their belief that, and I quote the translation from the reporter’s question, “God is punishing us for our sins,” that is to say that they ascribe to the position that the trial they are suffering is a result of God Almighty being angry with them. The converse being that where people are not suffering, God Almighty is happy with them? We know quite clearly from the Quran, the Sunnah, from the teachings of Prophet Muhammad, that trials are not set upon people purely because they were sinners, rather, trails have been set upon people to see how they respond to the change of circumstance. A subtle but very important difference.

And within their mindset sits another troubling revelation. For weeks now some aid agencies have complained that their staff have been intimidated and obstructed by al-Shabaab, so much so that the World Food Program has had to pull out of the region. There has been much speculation on why this is the case, and now their spokesman has given us the answer, he said, “We ask Muslims to help us so that we do not have to rely on help from unbelievers.”

So to make their point, to discriminate aid based on the faith of the one offering it, and to deny those who are suffering because of this ugly interpretation of Islam, they call this sharia law? I can’t help but say to them that God Almighty is in fact punishing you for your sins, your stupidity sits in the same category of the uneducated, pre-Islamic fools who acted not with the subject of justice to mind, but to seek political authority, whatever the cost.

Amongst one of the charities that do have access to the region and who are authorized to provide support are Islamic Relief, the UK based charity which is one of the many tied in to the Disasters and Emergency Committee group. I wonder why al-Shabaab haven’t raised concerns given the interaction Islamic relief has with non-Muslims? After-all, if all non-Muslims are ‘out to get the Muslims’ then surely by working with non-Muslims, Islamic Relief are conspiring with them. Absurdity leads to absurdity.

As for those actually within Islamic Relief, it must be a bitter pill to swallow, to provide the much needed aid they have to ignore the politics of al-Shabaab and do what needs to be done; providing help to those who need it. This is of course the mandate of all respectable charities, including I might add, the world food program.

I’m just frustrated that once again we have another band of self righteous Muslims who are using Islam as a means of creating division, adopting obscure, even unIslamic principles, dressing them up as a means and path towards piety and righteousness. Ironically, this reminds me of the Rhetoric used by Anders Breivik, where hate, mistrust, even anger is channeled onto external parties. What do al-Shabaab and Anders Breivik share in common? They identify problems (more imaginary than real), they assign blame onto a third party, they then enforce injustice as a means of delivering what they believe to be truth.

The Quran is very clear, warning about such mindsets: “O People of the scripture, do not exceed the limits of your religion beyond the truth, and do not follow the vain desires of people who went astray before you, who misled many, and who strayed themselves from the right path (5:77)”

The context of this verse actually addresses the relationship between mankind and God, where instead of recognizing and worshipping God Almighty alone, some misrepresented the nature of god. The message contained is however general, it is a warning to not misrepresent Islam. Which is exactly what al-Shabaab have done by finding pathetic reasons to obstruct the deliver of much needed aid to a population suffering a famine.

When I see the way al-Shabab is acting there, I am reminded of another verse of the Quran, “They did not forbid one another from the wrong they would commit. Vile indeed was what they used to do (5:79)” And Prophet Muhammad said, “By He in Whose Hand is my soul! You will enjoy righteousness and forbid evil, or Allah will send a punishment on you from Him. Then, you will supplicate to Him, but He will not accept your supplication (Ahmed 5/388)”

My advice to al-Shabaab: Stop creating excuses to reject aid as this is an injustice and what you are doing is wrong. Do not be so paranoid so as to suggest that the world food program has any objective other than to help those who are suffering. Do not be so arrogant and proud to assume that every non-Muslim is out to abuse the Muslims, for it is clear that even Muslims take advantage of Muslims (most recent examples include Mubarak in Egypt, Asad in Syria). Instead when you find truth, justice and fairness, work with truth justice and fairness, even if those displaying those attributes have a different religion (Prophet Muhammad was an excellent example of seeking peace with and establishing mutual terms with non-Muslims whenever possible). If you continue this path you are committing an injustice. And while people are sometimes tested to determine the strength of their faith, if you continue the path of rejecting good resulting in harm and injustice for the very people you claim to be representing, as the words of the Prophet himself from the hadith above state, Allah may actually send a punishment on you from Him.

Further, think about this. Could it be that this famine has affected your region such that you are forced to interact with non-Muslims such that you move away from your distrust of non-Muslims carte blanche? Could this be God Almighty’s way of helping you realise the futility of certain religious positions you have adopted such that you become less narrow minded and more accepting of the wider human condition. Think about it, and Allah knows best.

May Allah Almighty protect us from foolishness when interpreting faith, protect us from extremism which diminishes faith, and guide us towards a path where societies can come together on common terms for mutual prosperity and success in this life and the next, ameen.

Posted in Fasting, Islam, Ramadan | Leave a comment

O People, O Believers

“O People (ya ayyuha ‘l-nas),” “O Believers (ya ayyuha ‘lladhina amanu),” together these phrases appear 151 times in the Quran, occurring more frequently in the areas that address divine law.  Grammatically, these phrases are addressing a live audience, that is the Prophet and the people around him. However practically, these phrases target the wider audience, everyone who hears the message, across the generations that follow.

By contrast, these phrases differ to messages directed specifically to the Prophet, for example: “It has been revealed to you and those before you: If you associate other gods with God, our work will fail (39:65)” – all the while the meaning of even these statements are a guidance. That is, while this verse is directed specifically to the Prophet, it’s substance is relevant to everyone.

I refer to these two types of verses as I ponder something overtly simplistic.

The Quran as a set of words is characteristically a ‘guidance’ to mankind, but beyond this, it is a dialogue. While some verses were in response to particular events that took place, others were not. Irrespective, the Quran becomes very much a conversation between two parties, the Addressor and the addressee; in other words between Allah Almighty, and everyone else.

Allah Almighty says, “O you who believe, do not follow the khutuwat of satan (24:21).” The word khutuwat has been interpreted to mean, the actions of satan, the evil whisperings of satan, even vowing to commit a sin. There is no restriction on time or place, there is no wider context or meaning, the verse is simple: something for everyone, with an uncomplicated message, do not succumb to temptation or do wrong.

But it’s this word khutuwat which troubles me. On the one hand there is a message which is either directed to me specifically (O People, O believers), or directed to me by implication by way of guidance made directly to the Prophet. In effect this is a conversation between me and The Creator. Thus if I’m reading the Quran without understanding it’s message, neither literal nor implied, what value does this conversation have to me?

Put it another way. I’m sitting in a room full of people and someone starts speaking in Spanish. At best I look over and glance at the individual, then come to realise the conversation isn’t relevant to me so ignore it. At worse, the person is trying to communicate with me, but due to the language barrier cannot deliver their message.

Thus, when I hear or recite the Quran, when I am having this conversation with Allah, if I do not understand the conversation, am I subject to khutuwat, am I following the footsteps of satan, am I committing a sin? Perhaps, but I wouldn’t go that far, as the very act of trying to communicate is an exerted effort with the right intention.

Still, I know enough to know that there is within a call from God Almighty. I’m being addressed, you’re being addressed, we’re all being addressed. The question is, our response.  So I pray that the blessings of this ramadan bring us all a better comprehension of faith such that we the people, we the believers, can know better what it is we believe, such that perhaps one day, we may have a better response when called, ameen.

Posted in Fasting, Islam, Ramadan | Leave a comment

The ‘Time’ Of Expectation

On my way into London by train, the route traverses a wide array of buildings refecting architecture throughout the ages. From ancient churches to contemporary buildings throughout the 60s, 70s, 80s, 90s and 00s. It is as if each generation is leaving it’s mark on the landscape. All the while the landscape itself has it’s own purpose. For example, a line of trees as you near Waterloo station, all growing to a certain height all to a certain shape, represent their own purpose.

As I step through the barrier at the station, I move past a mother and child who have just walked through the machine, all the while the child, no more than five or six, had left her ticket on my side of the barrier. Without a moments thought, I automatically pick it up and pass it to the mother. Equally, without a moments thought she acknowledges the action with a thank you carrying on.

I would love to say that it is my nature to do good deeds in such a way without thought but that would be far too presumptuous. However those moments earlier today reflected a series of expectations based on circumstance, all of which were met.

So I ask myself about expectations. As a child I expect my parents to provide for me, food, water, shelter, an education. As I grow, my expectations change till eventually (and perhaps one day inshallah), I’ll be responsible for fulfilling such expectations. But it’s not just a parent-child relationship but the way we interact with society through our work, our social lives, and more.

Despite it’s enticing strap-line, “Your world. Your way,” after Yahoo purchased e-groups many years ago, I have never been able to access my old egroup with ease. Navigating the platform is an absolute nightmare leaving me with an utterly frustrating experience. Yet I still do it as some of my old files are stored on their ‘cloud’ service. Even now, literally right now as I try to access the service to pull up a hadith reference, it says “There’s a new master of the digital universe. You” and instead of letting me sign-in, I receive a message reading ‘The connection was reset.’ Yet ironically I have no problem with any other web page. I have for years expected a poor service, and unsurprisingly, that is exactly what Yahoo have delivered to me, any wonder the brand is Yahoo! – where the exclamation mark probably reflects other people’s frustration. At least the expectation was met!

Anyway, back on to the main topic, expectation. It is reported that Allah Almighty has said, “There are two joys for My servant who fasts. The first is at the time of breaking the fast, and the second is when he will meet his Lord.”

It is further reported that one of the gates to paradise, named Rayyan, has been designated only for those who were regular in fasting. And that the person who fasts for the sake of God Almighty alone, they repel the heat of hell fire by the distance travelled on a 70 year journey.

Now I’m trying to contextualize the implication and meaning of these statements. Paradise, let alone a gate to paradise, are two things which mankind simply cannot comprehend. Similarly, a journey of 70 years? That is non stop travel for nearly as long as a person lives. If I complain about a 60 minute commute into London, how can I possibly understand the impact of such a distance? But then it occurred to me, perhaps I’m over thinking this.

One of the most succinct chapters of the Quran is Surah Al-Asr (meaning, Time) which reads:

1. By Time
2. Verily mankind is at a loss
3. Except, those who have faith, who perform good deeds, who advice one another to the right path, and who recommend one another to be patient

It then hit me, my expectations are centered around time. If I do something, if I go somewhere, if I build something, if I grow something, everything that I do has a start and a finish, and with every start, there is an expectation for a finish. Much the same can be said about my life which started when I was a born and will finish the day that I die. Nothing happens before it’s due date and nothing will happen beyond it’s due date. This is the miracle of time.

I don’t really know where I am, and I don’t really know where I’m going. What I do know is that each day brings about a series of expectations – Thursdays, for example, are usually for Questiontime. Whether it is a university course, a job, a tv show, lunch with friend, this is what the first verse of this chaper of the Quran means to me, that time underpins everything.

But as the second and the final verse of the chapter confirm, in so far as we live through and manage our time,  unless we are being positive and productive with whatever it is that we are doing, then every expectation that we have managed is a loss.

I’m not suggesting a Groundhog day like revelation where Bill Murray first begins by trying to satisfy his futile desires eventually spending all of his time doing good everywhere he goes. That is a (great!) movie for entertainment and it sits at an extreme. Equally avoid the other extreme where you reject everything with a view of trying to become good, or better, or the best person. Instead, seek to find your balance.

Live with thought. Understand your actions and the repercussions of your actions. Be considerate. Don’t think that having fun is unIslamic, that entertaining yourself is the work of the devil, or watching tv is somehow haram. Focus on understanding the benefits of time, sharing the experiences you have had with others – not to show of, but to benefit from that experience. After all, if we really manage to better understand the value of time, we have truly been blessed.

Speaking of this chapter of the Quran, Prophet Muhammad once said, “If people spend time trying to understand this chapter, it will be sufficient to aid their understanding of faith.” To this I would add, that without understanding time, we will struggle to manage and deliver upon our expectations. Right or wrong, winning or loosing, both sets of extremes reflect neither wisdom nor understand. Instead, wherever we are and whatever it is that we do, let us seek to gain value from it. That to me is the truer understanding of expectation in the context of time.

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

From A Frown To A Smile

From “Gonna try and fast with the Muslims” to “You can not fast in Ramadan if you aren’t Muslim,” the twitter-sphere has been aflush with sentiment and expression.  While one wishes to share in the experience of fasting another denies them the right insisting on a religious exclusivity. Yet the Quran specifically observes, “O you who believe, fasting was prescribed for you, just as it was prescribed to those who came before you, so that you may learn self-control” (2:183).

Putting aside the tradition of fasting which can be seen across history as a means of spiritual purification and engagement with God Almighty, it is the foolish denial cited above, an unjustified restriction, which reminds me of a story in the Quran, the subject of Chapter Abasa (meaning, he frowned).

It so happened that one day Prophet Muhammad was speaking with one of the leaders of the tribe of Quraish with a view of educating him towards Islam. In mid conversation he was interrupted by a man named Ibn Umm Maktum, one of the earliest converts to Islam. Without hesitation he began speaking, asking the Prophet for guidance, but the Prophet counter-interjected asking him to wait while he finishes his conversation with the leader of the Quraish. In doing so, and perhaps even unknowingly, the Prophet, upset at the flow of his conversation, frowned at Ibn Umm Maktum – an almost mute point as the man was blind and couldn’t see the frown – before turning his attention back to the tribal leader. The opening verses of this chapter, below, criticise the Prophet’s actions:

1.He frowned and turned away
2. Because a blind man came to him
3. And how can you know that he might become pure
4. Or that he might receive admonition, and that will benefit him?
5. As for him who thinks of himself as self-sufficient
6. To him you attend
7. What does it matter to you if he will or will not become pure
8. But as for him who came to you running
9. And is afraid
10. Of him you are neglectful and divert your attention to another
11. Nay, indeed it (the Quran) is an admonition
12. So, whoever wills, let him pay attention to it

These verses reflect an interesting condition, the importance of offering sufficient time, help and guidance to all, irrespective of whether one is a powerful and wealthy tribal leader with influence, or an impoverished disabled individual. What struck me however was the order of priority. The Prophet didn’t reject the blind man, rather he delayed his response to him in favour of dialogue with another.Thus the Quran steps in advising him towards a better balance for engagement.

It is in this context that I found the comments on twitter troubling. On the one hand a person has shown interest in sharing the same experience Muslims have by fasting, while on the other hand, another admonishes them suggesting that fasting in Ramadan is something only a Muslim can do, and benefit from.

It is true that we are taught that fasting without the matched spiritual increment is akin to simply starving oneself (a similar message can be found in Judiasm and Christianity). But I would argue that by taking that first step, to perhaps better understand what Muslims are doing, to deny oneself food and water during daylight hours, these indicate a desire to at the very least empathise with the Muslims community. And the better any person understands another, irrespective of faith, the easier it will become for the world’s communities to find more in common. This alone should be sufficient merit to encourage shared experiences.

It also is reported in the explanation (tafseer) of the Quran authored by Qurtubi, that after this incident, whenever the Prophet met Ibn Umm Maktum – even though he was blind – he would always do so with a smile on his face. Further, in greeting him he would say, ‘Welcome to a man for whom my Lord has blamed me!’ This to me is one of the better indicators of the Prophet’s character where he is sufficiently humble so as to turn the criticism levied on to him by Allah Almighty into a friendly gesture.

Prophet Muhammad, upon whom be peace, once said, “Whoever seeks a path to knowledge, the path to paradise will be made easy for them.”

So I would encourage one and all not to place unwarranted restrictions, for when anyone seeks information, knowledge or advice about our faith, we should not to be so arrogant so as to ignore or even discourage them. Rather, we should should encourage and support them so that all of us – including Muslims who are just as needy of guidance – may find our way to the better path, ameen.

Posted in Fasting, Islam, Ramadan | 2 Comments