As an outsider it is difficult to understand the full merit of any revolution, particularly when the ‘call to arms’ in my own country, England, seemed more focused on self-enrichment through theft and mindless rioting. Yet in other parts of the world the Egyptians have shown us all the power of a meaningful revolution, while others, also subject to the rising of their people, are clinging on to whatever fumes of power and authority remain. With Assad of Syria and Gadaffi of Libya attacking their own citizens, we are also subject to the laughable prescription from the king of Saudi Arabia, delivering a warning to respect the wishes of his own citizens. The region is a mess.
Osama Bin Laden, wherever he is, dead or alive, is probably kicking himself. Like it or hate it, his call for a revolution was a decade too soon. Had he waited for the evolution of the internet, driving a campaign today via twitter, he may have been able to mimic the outcome of the Egyptian spring in Saudi Arabia. Of course the difference being that while in Egypt the call was for justice and freedom, the call pronounced by OBL was towards a more religious-centric society; that is to say the latter’s appeal was not towards the Egyptian style of revolution more towards replacing one form of tyranny with another. Imagine calling a society for religious reform based on the ugly face of ultra-conservative Islam, putting aside the fact that only those with closed minds such as Anders Breviek might heed the call, it isn’t religious authority but religious freedom that gives any nation success.
Prophet Muhammad once said that the person who harms a non-Muslim living amongst the Muslims, it is as if they have harmed him directly. This isn’ta phrase that should be light on the tongue for it’s meaning and implication are truly profound. 1400+ years ago, not only did the Prophet instill the values of respect and justice towards all, but he stressed the importance of protecting minority communities. At the most extreme interpretation, another of his statements sheds lights: Do not allow your dislike of a people lead you to be unjust towards them.
These values of freedom have drawn the line between those of us living in the ‘free world’ vs others. Yet ironically it is these same values of freedom which are being loosely tossed around like a salad. The French businessman Rachid Nekkaz who has set up a fund to pay fines for women wearing face veils is perhaps the epitome of this freedom. Like the vast majority of Muslims, he actually disagrees with the face veil, yet, he will stand up for a person’s right to dress as they like. This isn’t about religion, it is about the values of freedom, and the message of justice. If societies continue to blur these lines – for cheap political gain – then we become no different to the oppressors we criticise elsewhere.
During the early days of Islam there was a man named Shas ibn Qays. He was an older man who disliked Islam, and one day, when walking past a group of Prophet Muhammad’s companions he became envious at their happiness and unity, such that, he pronounced to himself, ‘If the chiefs of the tribe of Qayla in this country unite, there will be no place for our tribe with them.’ Ironically, the stability and success of Mecca at the time was not in mutual co-operation and goodwill, rather found in the instability of the differing warring tribes. If some of the tribes united, they might pose a threat to the other tribes. And so he sent a young boy to sit with that group of men instructing him to relate the story of the battle of Bu’ath.
During this battle two tribes, the Aus and the Khazraj fought, with one being victorious. As the young boy began reciting poetry – a way of story telling, suggesting the strength of one tribe over the other, tempers flared, and the peace these people had, had crumbled. Long story short, they became angry and decided to go to war. As news reached the Prophet he called them together reminding them that the past is the past and they must work together to secure the future. Realising their foolishness their apologised to one another. This to me sums up where not only Libya, but much of the Muslim world is today.
Just for a moment, forget faith, because actually, this isn’t about faith – if you ask every one of these people they will all confirm that they believe in One God. This is about tribes and clubs. This is about pride and arrogance. Whether it’s in the changing Muslim world or the static Muslim world, this is about ancestry and entitlement. It is actually the same story of when the black stone was being placed in the Kaba, every tribe wanted to do it, but peace was only found when every tribe was able to do it.
As I sit here watching events unfold in the Muslim world, I’m not interested in the motivations eluded to by OBL, nor those of the Taleban – I’ve simply never understood either of their causes or the rationale either chose to adopt for murdering and inflicting injustice en masse.
Love it or hate it, Arabia became Saudi Arabia as the tribe of Saud was able to unite the different tribes of Arabia under a single umbrella to deliver stability and thus generate excessive wealth. It is that wealth which ensured that the tribe remained in place, so long as other tribes are paid off handsomely for their solemn acceptance. How critical can any of us be of that given that it is the same stability which ensures a relatively steady supply of oil ensuring the global economy churns – I do not know.
What I do know is that Libya’s oil fields are vast. It’s the reason why we are in Libya and not in Syria. What I hope however is that in securing peace and stability, the Libyans look beyond tribal loyalty and adopt a form of democracy. Sure, this is what was tried in Afghanistan and has proven to be a laughable joke – as once again for anything to be done it has to go through the lines of tribal authority, all the while those on top of the pyramid are enriching themselevs at the cost of their citizens.
Technology has delivered an impressive change, the problem is, bits and bytes are easy to program, people’s attitudes and allegiances are not.
As Libya enters a new era, I pray they find success through mutual co-operation, justice and accountability. The older example of Saudi Arabia’s stability and the more recent example of Afghanistan’s instability are evidence to suggest this will not happen. Still it is a new world. Egypt is setting an interesting precedent and we are all learning something new everyday. Who knows, perhaps the Libyans will be able to do a better job. Time alone will tell.
As for me, as an outsider, as a person with a small voice, the best I can offer is a prayer of goodwill. And may that which is better for the people of Libya be made easy for the people of Libya, ameen.
